Keep your eye on the bull. Never turn your back on the bull.
On the way home from the barn yesterday, Henry said that he wants to write a story about a goat that goes on an adventure. Quietly, my hands at the wheel, my heart leaps a bit. Riley said, "Oh yeah! Like the Miraculous Adventures of Edward Tulane?" And Henry replied that goats can move on their own, so not really so much like Edward Tulane's adventures, but hopefully a solid story none the less. Riley was quite excited by this. She chirped and clucked with all sorts of supportive ideas. I was still quietly listening, biting my lips. Ry finished by reminding Henry there is no pressure, what so ever, for him to actually write the story anyway. She made it clear though, she is in full favor of the idea.
I said, "Well that is one good idea for a homeschooling project. Let me know if you need any more paper or a new typewriter ribbon or just any thing at all. I'll be happy to help in any way I can." The kids kept chatting. I'm not sure what they were talking about because I was lost in a mire of 100 things I wanted to say. I wanted to remind Henry that Christopher Paolini wrote Eragon as a homeschooling project. (No pressure.) I wanted to ask him if he knew the elements of a story, which I was simultaneously reviewing in my head. You need a beginning, middle, and end. (Duh.) I wondered if I should offer a writing guide: Strunk and White perhaps? Oh yes, my mind was an educational whirl wind. Amazingly, I kept silent.
The backseat chatter filtered through my thoughts. The children were laughing and I heard Henry, dripping irony and good humor, say, "Yes, and don't forget characters! I find that characters really bring a story to life!" Oh my God, unknowingly, he was mocking my thoughts. I have nothing to teach this kid. If he ever writes the story, what he'll need is an editor. Maybe we can hire Aunt Karin? Never the less, the actual story is beside the point. Ry is exactly correct, the story is a foot note. The lesson is for me. Henry has already learned how to write. The rest of the way home Henry retold the Inheritance Trilogy without characters, save for one grasshopper.
The bull is not in Henry's story. The bull is back on the farm in the pasture where we can keep our eye on him.
I am constantly amazed by unschool. When I hear anyone begin to speak about what their kids are learning, I panic inside. I am never quite sure what my kids are learning. Because, I do very little teaching. Very Little Teaching. What amazes me over and over and over again, is that my children are learning. (They are learning how to read and write. They are learning current events and history. They are learning math and science. Art? Please.) It is a true mystery and a paradox. All I can do, really, is keep coming back here to write it all down. And here, perhaps, I can pull threads out of the mystery. I have one thread for you now. The less time the children spend in class, the more time they have to learn.
Which begs the question, why school? Why not school? I need everything I learn. Nothing I learn is ever wasted. I shudder before all I do not know. How could anyone justify not teaching, when learning is...everything. Learning Is Everything.
When we had Raspberry's horns dug out and cauterized we created two huge wounds on her head. When they eventually festered and sprouted maggots I got very concerned. I insisted on calling the vet and medicating her. When more maggots were found, I lost my patients and my calm and I made the vet drive all the out to our farm to look directly at my cow and her festering wounds. He was cool. I like him a lot. But he said he has never lost a cow to dehorning, not once, ever. There have been no fatalities in his practice. He said that cows are tough. You could dehorn 10 of them, send them out into the pasture for a year, and they would come back healed up just fine.
He patted my head. He gave me more medicine and instructions which, he subtly implied, were more for my benefit than Raspberry's. And he left. And I tended her, armed with my maternal will, some new found bravery (you try tying up a 400 pound calf and washing maggots out of her head,) and all my shiny new knowledge. I paid good money for that information. And I put it to use. She has slowly gotten better. While she is not yet healed, I am no longer too worried. I learned a lot from the vet.
So yesterday we turned Raspberry out into the pasture. As is our routine, we greeted her, gave her a treat, brushed her down, loved her up, and then walked her to the pasture. She stood in the morning sun lowing for the herd. Who came to find her?
The bull came around the corner and touched noses with my cow. She lifted her face to him with utter deference and relief, it seemed to me. He stood with her and sniffed her all over her face. And he began to lick her. And while I kept my eye on him, he cleaned every bit of her face. Over and over he licked her, paying special attention to her horn holes.
And it hit me all in a flash. We know, not much. Yet, we insist on teaching. How about that bull? I should spend more time just watching him.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
I'm in agony over this. Did I say it right? Does this make sense? I know it is paradoxical - including my own bad writing, what I could learn from a decent writing class, and how maybe an actual writer could teach the kid a thing or two. I know, there is always more to learn.
But for elementary school, especially, what they can learn when you gather the bravery Not to teach, is astounding. At least I find myself astounded by them and what they learn.
And then I think, what the bull already knew about caring and healing and teaching... How, if I'd set that little calf out with the herd, she would have faired better and faster. Then with my children, I see the parallel. Which makes me question, again, all those kids in school.
stop Katherine. Stop talking about it now.
As vile as they are, I guess maggots in a situation like that, are not the worst thing that could happen. They keep necrotic tissue down, so bacteria is also decreased. I know, I know.
We once rescued a golden retriever who was neglected. Her owners had put a little chain collar on her when she was small and never took it off as she grew. It embedded down into the flesh of her neck. We stole her from the garage when the neighbors were gone and when we saw her neck up close, and realized what was going on, we took her to the emergency vet.
The sedated her, cleaned her up, cut that chain off her neck, cleaned the wound, prescribed antibiotics. We were told that the sea of maggots was gross, but not harmful. Ugh. The car smelled like death for a week, even after being washed with Lysol and the windows open.
The dog got well and went to a new home, where she lived to be 14 years old. Her neck healed and curly golden red hair covered her scar.
Long story, I suppose. Hang in there, and thanks for sharing your adventure with us. love, V
Oh Val! wow. Thank goodness you saved that puppy.
Oh my god, and how much I fear the bull! He represents Mother Nature. He represents not school.
Does he/she finally know best?
STOP IT RIGHT NOW, young lady! Get back in your chair this very minute. Or you'll be sent to the Principal's office for embarrassing yourself (again.)
"But for elementary school, especially, what they can learn when you gather the bravery Not to teach, is astounding. At least I find myself astounded by them and what they learn."
I find the only things my kids aren't learning is how to be in a classroom full of other kids and pick up on all the unwritten 'laws'. Usually it blows over their heads on playgrounds and with their friends, so not a problem so far. But in exchange the public school kids don't know what to do with the vast hours of free time my kids thrive in. Of course, gross generalizations both, but still something I observe day to day.
I could compare and contrast all day. Wallow in doubt and then turn around and marvel at some complex concept they've mastered. But in the end I know that they are growing and thriving as well rounded humans. Part of that well roundedness is a insatiable love for learning that will not allow them to become anything less than scholars. And while that isn't really the goal, it is good to have options.
I actually think that is what homeschooling is starting to be about for us. Having an unending supply of options.
Yes, I get everything you're saying.
Give Raspberry extra hugs for me the next time you see her.
I blubbered like a baby when I read the Edward Tulane book out loud to my kids.
The kids? The told me over and over: It will all work out in the end mom, don't cry.
Kids are such amazing creatures.
Isn't that a FANTASTIC book? Just the other day, I began to grasp the symbolism that Edward can't move.
Spiritually, we are like helpless dolls that get shoved around. We grow on the inside - or not. That's the only part we have control over.
love the book. so spooky. so good.
Post a Comment